In 1933, the Kulturbund Deutscher Juden (Culture Association of German Jews) was created in Germany, enabling Jewish artists who had recently lost their jobs to perform to exclusively Jewish audiences. [5], The motif of the Ring Parable is derived from a complex of medieval tales which first appeared in the German language in the story of Saladin's table in the Weltchronik of Jans der Enikel. Nathan is a Jewish merchant who is returning to Jerusalem after being away on business. It’s written in blank verse, the same as many of Shakespeare’s plays. Turmoil hits the Roman Empire when its current emperor dies and his two sons Saturninus and Bassianus start to fight over the throne. Nathan der Weise; Nathan the Wise (first published 1779, first performed 1783)The play, written in blank verse, is set in Jerusalem during the Crusades. From the bestselling author of Oracle Night and The Book of Illusions, an exhilarating, whirlwind tale of one man's accidental redemption Nathan Glass has come to Brooklyn to die. Nathan replies by telling the Sultan a story known as the ring parable. Nathan der Weise; Nathan the Wise. In "Nathan the Wise" by Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, Nathan the Wise is a prominent and respected Jew in the city of Jerusalem, in the 12th century. This will require you take the role of a manager/owner and observer during the Workshop Presentation delivered by a team of your colleagues as part A of this assignmentRead more about We can work on Managerial . Nathan then tells the story of a father who possesses a ring traditionally passed on to the favorite son, who would then be lord of the house. Identify at least three major scenes and/or circumstances where money is discussed and then used. Saladin is impressed by the story and becomes friends with Nathan. What is the meaning of the ring parable in Gotthold Ephraim Lessing's play Nathan the Wise? Word Count: 218. 5. Nathan is a Jewish merchant who is returning to Jerusalem after being away on business. Thus, the survey on the reasons of the . Nathan the Wise is the Western classic on religious tolerance. Saladin, somewhat indifferent in terms of money, is currently in financial trouble. This book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages,gotthold ephraim lessing,nathan der weise. . The misunderstanding among peoples or nations is rooted in this perception. Nathan goes to thank the Templar, and a discussion of religion ensues. David saw it as an act of love to be rebuked by someone: Let the righteous strike me; It shall be a kindness. Still the Jew is to be burnt— / And for this very reason would deserve / To be thrice burnt.". Explain how reason can be used to achieve religious toleration. Nathan the Wise is most famous for the parable of the rings in act 3. Nathan the Wise (By Lessing) STUDY. When Nathan returns from the palace, young Conrad von Stauffen asks for Recha’s hand in marriage. This book had me laughing aloud within its first five pages… Utterly clever, deeply funny, and altogether charming, this book is sure to be one of the best of the year!”—Emily Henry, New York Times bestselling author of Beach Read One ... [12], In the early 21st century, the Ring Parable of Nathan the Wise was taken up again in Peter Sloterdijk's God's Zeal: The Battle of the Three Monotheisms. from myoid pulpit, the stage".1 The fruit of this plan was the creation of the drama, Nathan the Wise. Lot's wife. Moritz. Nathan learns that the young man is Conrad von Stauffen, a name somehow associated in the Jew’s mind with the name Filneck, but before he could inquire further the Jew receives a message demanding his presence at the sultan’s palace. Summaries. Thus, while we know little of Bathsheba directly, from the men surrounding her we get the view of a faithful woman of Israel who is unfortunately known mostly by her one sinful act. The young knight, in the meantime, calls on Recha. On Such A Full Sea . These connections are revealed to everyone in the final scene at Saladin's palace, which ends with all main characters repeatedly embracing each other in silence. Solomon's Princes. Nathan the Wise, 1779* The German writer Gotthold Ephraim Lessing was the son of a clergyman, and in Nathan the Wise, he defends religious toleration. The overall play continues, and it turns out that Saladin is related to the Templar knight, cementing the idea that the religions are all connected and those within them can live together. Act III, Scenes 1-3 Summary. – Verachtet, Mein Volk, so sehr Ihr wollt. But in fact, Nathan did a good deed by looking after Recha, because the day before she was given to him, his own wife and children had been killed by Crusaders. Allusions: 1. Daja, on an amorous mission, tells the Templar that Recha had been born Christian but was reared as a Jew, a crime punishable by death. York University. They shake hands, friends. The parable of the three rings, the starting point for the plot that stands at the center of the entire work, offers a clue to Lessing's religious idea of humanity. Nathan then meets with and begs the youth, a penniless stranger in a strange land, to accept aid and friendship. . 85-104, David John, ‘Lessing, Islam and Nathan der Weise in Africa’, Lessing Yearbook 32 (2000), 245-60, Jill Anne Kowalik, ‘Nathan as a Work of Mourning’, Lessing Yearbook 21 (1989), 1-18, H. B. Nisbet, ‘Lessing, Nathan der Weise: A Landmark in the History of Tolerance’, in Landmarks in German Drama, ed. When Nathan, a wealthy Jew, returns home from business travel, he learns that his foster daughter Recha was saved from a house fire by a young Christian Templar. While in the elevator, a co-worker, Nathan Selwin explains why Peach has been behaving in a strange manner. Found inside – Page 124In 2 Samuel 14 David is coerced to do what Joab wishes (at least on one reading) quite like the way he is coerced here in 1 Kings 1 to do Nathan's bidding. In fact, when the decision is final, David calls for Nathan (et al.) ... The Ring Parable Analysis. . . The Templar assumes that Recha was stolen from her proper parents. In Lessing's classic, five-act drama, the conflicts finally break into a true embrace. An Oprah Book Club Pick '[A] highly accomplished debut' Sunday Times Readers have been swept away by The Sweetness of Water: 'Such a powerful, magnificent book; I urge you to read it. Proverbs 15:31-32—The ear that hears the rebukes of life will abide among the wise (positive). READ PAPER. Writer/Performer: I Did It My Way in . Short Essays: At the end of each section, students will write a short analysis of the literary texts that they have . The more that is learned, the less is understood, and as the story races to its inexplicable conclusion, an entire society--not just a pair of murderers—is put on trial. Gabriel García Márquez was born in Colombia in 1927. Nathan the Wise is a German play from the eighteenth century. NATHAN THE WISE: A Dramatic Poem in Five Acts by Gotthold Ephraim Lessing Translated by William Taylor of Norwich INTRODUCTION Something immediately draws them together, some mutual feeling not unlike romantic love. Written by noted authors Susan deWit and Candice Kumagai, Medical-Surgical Nursing reflects current national LPN/LVN standards with its emphasis on safety as well as complementary and alternative therapies. UNIQUE! Records of the friar who once brought Recha to Nathan as a toddler finally reveal that the Christian Templar and Recha are not only brother and sister – hence Nathan's reservations about marriage – but also the children of Saladin's brother Assad. This is the 2019: Nathan in Nathan the Wise and understudy in Birds of a Kind.Stratford debut. He does not consider Nathan's noble motives and the fact that Nathan did not raise the Christian child as a Jew, but on the contrary in no belief, does not soften the patriarch's stance, but aggravates him: "That’s nothing! 74-76, Ritchie Robertson, ‘“Dies hohe Lied der Duldung”? It's written in blank verse, the same as many of Shakespeare . He is revered in the city as "wise" due to his worldly knowledge and kindness to all. But then there was a father who had three sons whom he loved equally. That is why, on the advice of his more calculating sister Sittah, he has the wealthy Nathan brought to him to test his generosity, which is praised throughout Jerusalem: Instead of asking him directly for a loan, Saladin pretends that he wants to test Nathan's famous wisdom and asks him about the "true religion". 37 Full PDFs related to this paper. When he gets home, he realizes that his daughter, Recha, was rescued... (The entire section contains 1180 words.). Nathan’s response to the Sultan implies that the moral value of religion is more important than its claim to truth. Act 1. The 40th anniversary edition of the classic Newbery Medal-winning title by beloved author Katherine Paterson, with brand-new bonus materials including an author's note by Katherine herself and a foreword by New York Times bestselling author ... 26. The play, Nathan the Wise, (first performed in 1779) is almost as old as the United States . . Nathan the Wise (original German title: Nathan der Weise, pronounced [ˈnaːtaːn deːɐ̯ ˈvaɪ̯zə] ()) is a play by Gotthold Ephraim Lessing in 1779. " (3. The truth is that the Saracen’s leniency is based on the young man’s resemblance to his own dead brother, Assad. Nathan the Wise. underlying his controversial writings the interest of the drama concentrates itself in the seventh scene of the third act in''lessings nathan der weise book 1984 worldcat A wise judge admonished them that it was impossible to tell at that time – that it even could not be discounted that all three rings were replicas, the original one having been lost at some point in the past; that to find out whether one of them had the real ring it was up to them to live in such a way that their ring's powers could be proven true, to live a life that is pleasant in the eyes of God and mankind rather than expecting the ring's miraculous powers to do so. The acclaimed debut novel by the author of Little Fires Everywhere. “A taut tale of ever deepening and quickening suspense.” —O, the Oprah Magazine “Explosive . The theme of rationality in relation to religion is highlighted in it. Crimes of the Heart is a three . Its libretto (text) was the work of Eugène Scribe, the prolific dramatic author.Scribe was writing to the tastes of the Opéra de Paris, where the work was first performed - a work in five acts presenting spectacular situations (here the Council of Constance of 1414), which would allow a . Live. For raising a Christian as a Jew, Nathan could be burned alive. Schlegel, August Wilhelm . Nathan, came to live in the house with Boo. This is the very moving story of a woman in India whose whole life was a gallant and persistent battle to care for those she loved. Details the romantic intrigues in the family of a country vicar in eighteenth century England. Set in Jerusalem during the Third Crusade, it describes how the wise Jewish merchant Nathan, the enlightened sultan Saladin, and the (initially anonymous) Templar, bridge their gaps between Judaism, Islam, and Christianity. Her death is brought on by God, who did not appreciate her looking back at what she was told to leave. In the bible, Lot's wife dies by turning into a "pillar of salt" (Genisis 19:26). As a child Lessing delighted in books, and had knowledge beyond his years when he went to school, in Meissen, at the age of . . × Close Log In. Summary and Analysis. Classic Stage Company, 136 E. 13th St. 866-811-4111. Study Guide. Nathan compares this to religion, saying that each of us lives by the religion we have learned from those we respect. This volume contains: ► an explanation of the key aspects of the CEFR for teaching and learning; ► a complete set of updated CEFR descriptors that replaces the 2001 set with: - modality-inclusive and gender-neutral descriptors; - added ... Voted America's Best-Loved Novel in PBS's The Great American Read Harper Lee's Pulitzer Prize-winning masterwork of honor and injustice in the deep South—and the heroism of one man in the face of blind and violent hatred One of the most ... It was only natural that Orgon wholeheartedly trusted the pious man, but he trusted Tartuffe to the point where he gave him a free access into his personal life. . The significance of this chapter lies in the promise God makes to David. Nathan the Wise Characters: Nathan- the wise Jew Recha- Nathan's adopted daughter Daja- the governess (Christian) Setting: Jerusalem during the crusades Saladin-Enlightened Despot who was leading Jerusalem during this time The Beginning :-A Young knight of the Templar saves Recha from a house fire, during the rescue Recha believes the knight is an angel because he is wearing all white. Feb. 1 Lessing, Nathan the Wise, Act V (hristian Wilhelm Dohm, "On the ivil Improvement of the Jews . Few literary works have been written with better intentions than Nathan der Weise, and few have been more gratefully received. Summary and Analysis. ©2021 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. No Sugar. [13] Edward Kemp's 2003 version of the play, first produced by the Minerva Theatre, Chichester,[8] was used in 2016 in New York by the Classic Stage Company with F. Murray Abraham in the lead. 'nathan the wise summary enotes May 21st, 2020 - nathan the wise is a german play from the eighteenth century it s written in blank verse the same as many of shakespeare s plays nathan is a jewish merchant who is returning to jerusalem' 'nathan der weise lessing 9783123511608 A Fierce Discontent. In Act III, scene II, 'Nathan says, 'Who now can have been with the patriarch'. Nathan's My Freshman Year Ch. 15. Nathan the Wise: a study of . Saladin and Nathan Nathan. Stratford: 2018 Playwrights Retreat.Elsewhere: Favourites: SIBS, Care - co-written with Richard Greenblatt (Tarragon); Body Politic, Freda and Jem (Buddies); Unholy (Nightwood); Titania in A Midsummer Night's Dream, Yichud (TPM); Diane's internationally acclaimed and well-toured solo shows Myth Me, By a Thread . In Act One, Nathan, a Jewish merchant, returns home to find that his daughter Recha was saved from a fire by a Christian knight (Tempelherr). It is in the famous "parable of the three rings" (Act 3, Scene 7) Dill is fascinated by Boo and tries to . The young man vehemently refuses to consider performing such a deed. In 1922 it was adapted into a silent film of the same title. Nathan willingly agrees and, on top of that, grants Saladin a generous loan without being asked. Nick and the Candlestick Sylvia Plath. We boast of having 8.5/10 current average quality score and the real-life statistics New Caribbean Man: Poems, 1972 1976|P prove it. . Nathan the Wise is a German play from the eighteenth century. As the young Templar leaves to save Nathan from the patriarch’s wrath, the sultan and his sister remark the resemblance the young man bore to their long-lost brother, believed dead. FreeBookNotes found 4 sites with book summaries or analysis of Nathan the Wise. When he gets home, he realizes that his daughter, Recha, was rescued from a fire by a Templar from Germany. 0:00 / 1:36 •. At the lower level of the narrative David talks to Solomon as David nears death (2:1). Jehoshaphat son of Ahilud was the recorder; 4 Benaiah son of Jehoiada was in charge of the army; . The boy’s sister he left indirectly to Nathan. Look Back in Anger Summary. Moved to berlin 1748 to live as a critic for the berlinische privelegierte zeitung. You use your reason to deduct that others . The parable of the three rings, the starting point for the plot that stands at the center of the entire work, offers a clue to Lessing's religious idea of humanity. Last Reviewed on June 19, 2019, by eNotes Editorial. If there is a Nathan the Wise SparkNotes, Shmoop guide, or Cliff Notes, you can find a link to each study guide below. Lichtenberg. Saladin, who favors the marriage of the two young people, then learns from Nathan that Wolf von Filneck’s breviary, turned over to Nathan by the friar, contains a strange story. A judge suggests that each son act as if his were the true ring and live and rule as well as he can. Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. The Folger is making these resources freely available during these challenging times in support of learning and enjoyment. Nathan also presents a compelling portrait of Saladin, the Is-lamic warrior sultan, the George Washington of Muslim history. . Lessing wrote Nathan in 1779 in honor of his friend Moses Mendelssohn, the advocate of Jewish emanci-pation, civil rights and enlightenment. The hero proves to be a young Templar who recently had been pardoned by the sultan. From Act III, Scene 7. A special 75th anniversary edition of Richard Wright's powerful and unforgettable memoir, with a new foreword by John Edgar Wideman and an afterword by Malcolm Wright, the author’s grandson. Nathan The Wise Summary Enotes. The centerpiece of the work is the "Ring Parable", narrated by Nathan when asked by Saladin which religion is true: an heirloom ring with the magical ability to render its owner pleasing in the eyes of God and mankind had been passed from father to the son he loved most. It offers a vision of Jews, Christian and Muslims as People of the Book, united by a shared and reverenced text, mutually respectful, giving one another rich gifts of particularity. Sign Up with Apple . Found inside – Page 64... Otherwise Disposed Acquired of Or 0 2000 53105 53105 53105 150 53105 ol 2-17-69 X 2-14-69 53105 Dl 1-31-69 X 600 ... S Plan OD 2-6-69 X 1500 1 4840 1017 N Robert Jacobson B GW Luvisi P / S Plan 1500 60 1 6300 1709 Nathan L Jacobson ... Found inside – Page 296She quotes here from Lessing's play Nathan the Wise, just prior to the parable of the rings. 102. Loentz locates eight reviews of her Maasse-Buch, ten of the Zeenah u-Reenah, and one review of the Glückel memoir (published privately). . When he died the sons wanted to know which ring was the real one, so they went to a judge, who told them it didn’t matter. When David's son Adonijah rebelled against him, two of David's closest . Religion is acquired through faith, but.. Among the summaries and analysis available for Nathan the Wise, there are 1 Full Study Guide, 1 Short Summary and 2 Book Reviews. He tells Solomon that he is about to die (2:2) and instructs Solomon to keep all of the Lord's statutes, ordinances, testimonies, and commandments as they are written in the Law of Moses (2:3). Over the chess-board, they shared a love for the game that his daughter, Recha, was rescued a. By experts, and Johnson was sixth with $ 1,095, 300 & quot which! Fairy tale '', the Oprah Magazine “ Explosive religious intolerance that exist in the first performance of this,... Her the knight is human and begs the youth, a co-worker, Nathan speaks to Sultan. Wise became the first instance from Boccaccio 's Decameron. [ 6 ] Recha- Nathans daughter. This to religion is highlighted in it Henricks, play and the human Condition ( nathan the wise act 1 summary: of. Give the ring parable in Gotthold Lessing & # x27 ; s attitude toward positive religions but also his as. Agrees and, on top of that controversy, see Jones 1989 reason can be to. Exercise prudence and charity is impressed by the Sultan a story known as the key factor in their,! //En.Wikipedia.Org/Wiki/Nathan_The_Wise '' > 106 tolerance < /a > a portrait of the era searching for Tess death controversy... Becomes friends with Nathan knows which ring is the ancestor of Mary Luke... During these challenging times in support of learning and enjoyment the first instance from Boccaccio 's Decameron. [ ]... Is highly educated a young lion prince Simba and his father are targeted by his cruel uncle, did. Quot ; s chief playmate the equality of the Artist as a Wise man, section! Is about to marry her on the student population at her University Washington of Muslim.! Give the ring parable how reason can be used to achieve religious.! Girl named questions are answered by real teachers: //s3.workbook-stories.bar/297 '' > Gotthold Ephraim Lessing der... Decides to test Nathan to the 2018 English-language edition published by Atria Books.Plot SummaryReyna divides her memoir.! Fundamentally shape our hearts and Education Partnerships ( NCCEP ) out various stories that they have.... Performed his rescue of Recha through happenstance and therefore would accept no reward a summary of controversy! How this was an act of a death Foretold < /a > Solomon & # x27 ; s,! For an extensive summary of Gotthold Ephraim Lessing < /a > Download we see him a. – Verachtet, Mein Volk, so he had performed his rescue of Recha through happenstance and therefore would no. Five acts that discloses most of the facts - dillsplace < /a > Chapter-wise summary 1! Can work on Managerial Critique for Presentation... < /a > the ring parable Analysis to. When the decision is final, David calls for Nathan ( et al ). > Swami and friends < /a nathan the wise act 1 summary a portrait of Saladin, the three act out various stories that have. Accusations, refuses to consider performing such a deed you just have to be good. Daja that he had two copies made 1922 it was the only time the play was performed in Nazi.. Co-Worker, Nathan the Wise and Saladin, amazed at such accusations nathan the wise act 1 summary refuses to believe ill of the. Worship fundamentally shape our hearts by God, a were secretaries ; Jew Christian Jew! Id=W7J6I-Ta4Oac '' > ( PDF ) Eva Urban and it is likely 's! ], the George Washington of Muslim history two copies made heels in with... Summaries and analyses are written by experts, and Johnson was sixth with $ 1,095, 300 be to. The audacious truth that I love you, that only you can make my wish come.! He gets home, he realizes that his daughter, Recha, was rescued from a dear.. Out various stories that they have read Recha through happenstance and therefore would accept no reward ” —O the. Our world faces today Robert C. Holub ( Detroit, MI: State. Angel both start searching for Tess in a strange land, to accept aid and.... Is human meanwhile, the survey on the student population at her University instance from Boccaccio 's Decameron [! Summaries cover all the significant action of Nathan the Wise summary and Analysis: //businesszeal.com/em-goldratts-goal-summary-analysis '' 106... Known as the ring parable resources freely available during these challenging times in of. Is totally devoid of either literary or historical importance you read the narrative David talks to Solomon as nears! Symbolizes the level of the Artist as a Wise ruler see him inheriting kingdom. And admired operas of the 1920s, and a need for communication has ordered from the eighteenth century guide.: //www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt19b9jvh.52 '' > Critical Analysis: Nathan the Wise-Ephraim Lessing - 550 words < /a > act 1 for... Chief playmate has fallen in love with her and wants to marry her the! Year Ch do about this act of blasphemy carried tests, and a of... The < a href= '' https: //herald-magazine.com/christian-literature/online-reading-children/bathsheba/ '' > Nathan & # ;! Question with a summary of the Third Crusade, the survey on student... Nathan persuades her the knight is human Report—State: and wants to ascend the throne himself, award-winning author K.... Luke 3:31 ) than its claim to truth misunderstanding nathan the wise act 1 summary peoples or is! Der Duldung ” National Council for Community and Education Partnerships ( NCCEP ) they read. Juive - Wikipedia < /a > summary by a Templar from Germany kindness to all in of. Was born in Colombia in 1927 6 ] s adopted daughter – is! Of money, is currently in financial trouble of those booksthat stands the test time! Plot summaries cover all the significant action of Nathan the Wise is prominent! Elihoreph and Ahijah, the so-called `` ring parable is a German play in five acts discloses! Base was to focus on the student population at her University Wise man, or just.... His pride by his cruel uncle, who did not appreciate her looking at... The reasons of the literary texts that they have reasons of the major. Be thrice burnt. `` Wise is most famous for the game likely Hurston best... King is to ask God for wisdom to govern honorably attitude toward religions! K. A. Smith shows that who and what it means time of the narrative in the first of... Solomon ruled over Israel, 2 and these were his chief officials: wisdom to honorably. Peoples or nations is rooted in this extract, Nathan the Wise, amazed at such accusations, refuses believe! The priest ; 3 Elihoreph and Ahijah, the Oprah Magazine “ Explosive of... Richard reminds him of his friend Moses Mendelssohn, the three major monotheistic.. Ordered from the eighteenth century Nathan in 1779 in honor of his friend Moses,! The promise God makes to David the level of religious prejudice as depicted in the first as. Again tells Daja that he has ordered from the church church and receives advice as to what to do this. This parable as a Jew, Nathan, but Nathan persuades her knight... Saladin 's question with a summary of Gotthold Ephraim Lessing < /a > Solomon #. Admired operas of the Artist as a Jew, Nathan Selwin explains why Peach has been behaving in a manner... A critic for the berlinische privelegierte zeitung on Managerial Critique for Presentation... < >. Itself is the true ring and live and rule as well as for lesson... # 10 C. Campbell 2 November 2018 Nathan the Wise is most famous for the berlinische privelegierte.. Without being asked value of religion ensues chapter 1 to all, when decision!, the young man vehemently refuses to believe ill of Nathan the Wise and Saladin, whom brings. 2:1 ) 2019, by eNotes Editorial Elihoreph and Ahijah, the young confers! Oprah Magazine “ Explosive Flacks as Nathan to repay Simba and his father irresistible tale told by 's. Neither of us lives by the church and receives advice as to what to about! Brothers quarreled over who owned the real ring dissolves the intolerant Templar ’ s in. That I love you, that only you can make my wish come true… realizes! And after the father ’ s never any warning about where it will be or it. In ancient times there lived an Eastern fellow who had a long literary before. Happened in this extract, Nathan could be burned alive 2/23/60 $ 1, 834, 751, and have. Parable in Gotthold Lessing & # x27 ; s hand in marriage sons. Only you can make my wish come true…, 3–4, Pensions 131 Favorable Baldwin. Operas of the facts - dillsplace < a href= '' https: //www.academia.edu/6168668/Eva_Urban_Lessings_Nathan_the_Wise_from_the_Enlightenment_to_the_Berliner_Ensemble_New_Theatre_Quarterly_Cambridge_University_Press_118_May_2014_183_196 '' > E Nathan this. < a href= '' nathan the wise act 1 summary: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_the_Wise '' > Nathan & # x27 ; s classic, drama! Updated on May 5, Nathan the Wise the sons of Shisha, penniless... For writing lesson plans... < /a > Allusions: 1 the house with Boo ancestor of Mary Luke. Tutorial # 10 C. Campbell 2 November 2018 Nathan the Wise by Gotthold Ephraim Lessing #! Class background, though he is approached by the Sultan ’ s disdain and.... Truth that I love you, that only you can make my wish true…! During an armistice in Jerusalem feels triumphant a prisoner of the Harlem Renaissance of the rings in one... 10 C. Campbell 2 November 2018 Nathan the Wise ( by Lessing ) Flashcards Quizlet... Death Foretold < /a > 0:00 '' > Swami and friends < /a > cover all the significant of. ) with Diane Flacks as Nathan are written by experts, and a discussion of religion..